Fixed Wireless Broadband versus Fixed Line Broadband (ADSL, VDSL, Cable or Fibre)

Fixed Wireless Broadband versus Fixed Line Broadband (ADSL, VDSL, Cable or Fibre)
Wednesday, March 15, 2017

It is very important to understand the differences between these options when you are comparing internet providers and platforms.  The more you understand the better chance of choosing the plan that best suits your requirements.

TrueNet have been collecting and analyzing data in New Zealand on Fixed Wireless plans (the mobile 4G network) for the past 4 months and their first report was released earlier this week.  The results show Fixed Wireless is generally more comparable to ADSL, is considerably slower than VDSL, and far behind Fibre broadband.

 

One of the biggest areas to suffer was where ‘time of day’ affected webpage download performance significantly on Fixed Wireless' and Cable (Vodafone's Wellington and Christchurch cable networks).

TrueNet's latency tests show that Fixed Wireless Broadband has the highest Latency (delay) of all the technologies. Latency limits the maximum rate that information is transmitted across the Internet, which in turn affects the speed of webpage downloads, and the performance of online gaming sites.

Some topline reports are shown below which compare the different broadband connection types and you can visit our TrueNet pages for the latest news on the fastest ADSL broadband, fastest VDSL broadband and fastest Fibre broadband by clicking here or on the relevant link.

 

Thanks to Truenet for supplying this data.  The funding of most probes used in ADSL, VDSL Cable and Fibre are by the Commerce Commission.  Most of the Fixed Wireless probes were funded by Chorus.  

 

Fixed Wireless Broadband

Fixed Wireless broadband (referred to as Wireless in the speed charts below) is a connection that uses radio signals rather than fixed phone lines, cable or fibre.  This means it can be subject to interference such as weather, local demand from other users, or local topography - including buildings, hills or even trees and hedges.  A major benefit is that the gateway (modem/router/wifi) can be moved to different locations in your house and across the country because it only needs to be connected to power and be able to receive a ‘mobile’ signal.

For many rural broadband users, fixed wireless is often the only other option available for rural customers.   Fixed Wireless Broadband relies on a 4G network, so a good approximation of the quality of signal you could receive would be how good the signal strength on your smartphone is.

With all that in mind, for some Kiwis, Fixed Wireless is still the very best solution because they move regulalry, don't use the web for streaming or game playing and only have a small data consumption.  

Leading providers are Skinny and Spark. Compare their plans on Broadband Compare.

 

 

DEFINITION OF SPEED: For webpage speeds TrueNet measure the average speed of the page, taking the timing from the first packet to the last.  TrueNet choose a single page from a website that is approximately the same size as other pages, and likely to be active.  For file download speed TrueNet measure the best quartile speed for any download, which they refer to as the "Peak speed", these charts refer to the median of those measurements for each panelist, averaged over all panelists.

TrueNet use webpage viewing as the metric because this is critical to using the internet.  We shop, follow the news, and view social media on websites.  All technologies show some reduction in performance during the busiest hour, which is about 9pm, but Cable and Fixed Wireless have a much longer drop in performance.  It starts in the early morning and lasts all day, with cable dropping  to 90%, and Fixed Wireless to 85% of their available speeds at peak times.  

Please visit the TrueNet site for more information.

 

Related news
Should I upgrade to Gigabit Fibre during lockdown?
A week into lockdown one in five people remain worried about broadband coverage and quality with so many people at home. If your home...
Apr 3, 2020
Your daily broadband update during lockdown
As New Zealand moves through Stage 4 Lockdown to combat Covid-19, broadband providers are moving swiftly as essential service providers to keep New Zealanders...
Apr 3, 2020
What the upgrade to COVID-19 Stage 4 means for NZ Broadband
As New Zealanders sit through the Stage 4 lockdown in a bid to combat COVID-19, you may be wondering what this means for broadband...
Apr 1, 2020
Login
×
Log in with
Sign up for free NZ Compare account
×
Log in with
3 Great Offers
×
offer
EXCLUSIVE OFFER
Unlimited Fibre 100 - ONLY $62.95/mth
Terms and Conditions apply
offer
Special Offer - Get 2 months FREE
broadband on a 12-month term
with Skinny Unlimited Broadband
offer
Get $200 CREDIT and
Free Amazone Prime for a year*
Limited-time offer